I've heard many authors talk about how the characters in their stories seem to do things of their own volition, or about how the story seems to be outside of them rather than something they have created. It's easy to get this sensation when you're in the midst of creating - somewhat harder, I think, to retain it when you go back and start revisions.
In some ways, that sense of the story existing on its own can make us balk at revising. It's outside of us now, it has its own internal form and structure; the characters are who they are, and do what they do. In other ways, it's the sense that the story represents us as authors - that in a way, it is us - that causes us to hesitate.
I think considering the story as existing outside of us is perfectly fine. It may resist revision in some ways, but as long as we can consider the characters, the form and the structure from the outside, revision is possible. It's when we feel that we are the story that the revisions process can really defeat us. Then critique and requests for edits can feel like insults, and restructuring like an assault.
It's not that what we create isn't great. It isn't even that it's not publishable. I've seen whole books and famous movies that made me think, "needed one more rewrite." But though those books have been published and those movies produced, I always think it's a shame that that final revision never happened.
I've tried to train myself to take a particular view of my own work. To me, the story isn't me, and it isn't even what I've written. The story exists somewhere else - a plane of ideas, or some kind of Platonic dimension - where it exists in an ideal state. What I'm trying to do by writing it is capture that perfect spirit, that resonance, and convey it to my readers. Thus, revisions are the means by which I bring the story closer to the ideal. Maybe this is why I enjoy it so much!
Critique shows me how my readers understand what I'm doing; it gives me a sense of the pictures they see, and the resonance and intensity they feel. They aren't seeing the ideal form of the story any more than I am, but we're all trying, looking at it from different angles, and in that process we jointly get insight into what the story could be. Then once I feel I've glimpsed the way to get closer to what I want, I set about making it happen. Sometimes when I realize what the story really requires, and I feel a resonance come into place, it gives me goose bumps.
I'm not saying everyone has to think this way. What I'm trying to do is explain why I find revisions exciting instead of daunting. If what I'm sharing here helps any writer out there to take on the process of revisions with more relish and less sense of personal injury, then I'll be happy.
Great post. This is such an important concept to grasp if we're going to improve and be professional about our work. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThat makes perfect sense. Even though I rarely get that "story writing itself" kind of moments, I do treat the story as Story, an entity of itself. The characters are people to me, and it's my job to get their tale figured out properly in order to convey that reality to others. It's the flip side of how I read. The characters are people to me. Their world becomes reality while I'm reading.
ReplyDeleteYes! This is how I feel too. Whenever I change something, I feel like I'm that much closer to the ideal. That feeling is what keeps me going through all the criticism. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteThis is great! I have to fall out of love with my ms while doing revisions. It takes a different mindset. Thanks for this.
ReplyDeleteJuliette, I feel the same way. I see the revision process as a challenge. Sometimes it's tiresome, but it's exhilarating when you feel you've reached a balance point (not a final point - you are never finished polishing your story) and your story is always better than when it started. The story and the writer, I should say.
ReplyDeleteI think about the story in the similar manner. I feel like the job of revisions is to dig out the real story, because it is not always the same as what I've managed to put to paper.
ReplyDeleteWow, Fabio. Thanks for sharing your experience, and congratulations! It must be so satisfying to see a story land after all that effort.
ReplyDelete